News
Residents across the Central Coast say repeated use of incorrect or mismatched property images in home insurance assessments is delaying payouts and leaving flood-affected households stuck.
A growing number of Central Coast homeowners say their insurance claims have been delayed or incorrectly assessed after insurers attached duplicate or mismatched property photographs to their files — a problem that some residents believe has become more acute following successive flood events and the region's ongoing housing pressures.
The issue, broadly described as duplicate image replacement error, occurs when automated processing systems assign a photo from one property to a different address — or recycle an outdated image after a property has been renovated, damaged, or rebuilt. For households already navigating post-flood repairs or cost-of-living stress, even a short claims delay can mean weeks without a habitable home.
In suburbs including Lisarow, Narara, and along the Woy Woy peninsula — areas that have dealt with inundation and storm damage over the past three years — homeowners describe a frustrating pattern. They lodge a claim, an assessor reviews what appears to be their property, and a decision comes back that doesn't match the actual condition or structure of the building. In several cases, residents say the photograph attached to their assessment showed a different roof type, a different fence line, or a pre-renovation layout that no longer exists.
One Long Jetty resident, who did not wish to be named because their claim is still active, described receiving an assessment that referenced a carport their home had not had since a 2019 renovation. The claim was initially rejected on the grounds that the damage described didn't match the property profile on file. It took six weeks and a second site inspection to resolve.
The problem is not unique to any single insurer, and consumer advocates have noted it tends to surface most visibly after high-volume claim events — exactly the kind the Central Coast has experienced since the March 2021 floods, which caused widespread damage across low-lying suburbs between Tuggerah Lake and Brisbane Water.
The timing sharpens the stakes. Sydney recorded its hottest June since 1859 this year, and climate researchers have flagged the broader NSW coastal region as increasingly exposed to extreme weather. For Central Coast Council, which only exited formal financial administration in 2021 after a period of significant instability, the implications of delayed insurance outcomes flow into community infrastructure recovery as well as private claims.
The Central Coast Community Legal Centre, based in Gosford, has fielded inquiries from residents seeking help disputing claim decisions where property identification errors appear to be a factor. The organisation encourages residents to request a copy of all documents held about their property before an assessment is finalised — a step that can catch image errors early.
According to the Insurance Council of Australia's 2024 catastrophe event data, the Central Coast and Hunter regions together accounted for a material share of NSW's residential claims in the three years to mid-2025, though the organisation does not publish suburb-level breakdowns. The volume alone means even a small error rate in image matching creates a meaningful number of affected households.
The NSW Fair Trading office in Gosford handles disputes between consumers and insurers where internal resolution has failed. Residents can lodge a complaint there or escalate to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, which has a statutory obligation to respond within defined timeframes. AFCA's standard timeframe for insurance complaints is 30 days for acknowledgment and 45 days for a determination on straightforward disputes, though complex cases can run longer.
For homeowners concerned their file may contain outdated or incorrect images, the practical advice from consumer legal services is consistent: write to your insurer in the first instance requesting a full copy of your claim file under the Privacy Act, flag any discrepancy in writing rather than by phone, and keep a dated photo record of your property's current condition. Gosford's Service NSW centre on Mann Street can provide certified copies of council rate notices or development approval records, which can help establish a documented property history if a dispute escalates.
Spread the word
About this article
Published by The Daily Central Coast